It's no secret that education is a high-pressure field. Educators and school leaders tend to be perfectionists because they care about their students and want to help them. It might seem like the future of the world is resting on your shoulders at times. That's a big responsibility, and you probably feel like you have to be perfect to meet it.
At heart, everyone knows that perfection isn't possible. Teachers and school leaders are only human. There are times when they make mistakes or give less than 100% effort to a task. The good news is that imperfection isn't failure. You can be an asset to your school without being faultless. Being able to confront your inner perfectionist and grow from your mistakes is a strength.
The connection between perfectionism and mental health
The RAND Corporation analyzed the results of its 2023 State of Teaching (SoT) and American Life Panel surveys to determine how teacher wellbeing is impacted by the work environment. A staggering 58% of school staff reported that they experienced regular, job-related stress that affected their mental wellbeing.
Your Welbee toolkit includes resources to help you deal with anxiety and recognize depression. Learning how to manage your inner perfectionist is important too. When you break the cycle of perfectionism, you free yourself from unrealistic expectations and standards. It's great for your wellbeing and empowers you to try new approaches and methods as an educator.
Giving your best by giving up perfectionism
Making commitments to improve personal health and happiness can be hard for teachers. Educators are selfless, and they want to give their students the best classroom experience possible. Too often, striving for classroom perfection leaves teachers burnt out. It's important to have high standards and work diligently to meet student needs, but it's also essential to be kind to yourself.
You show up and support your students. You are a good teacher because you aren't perfect. All teachers and school leaders want their students to be well-prepared in school and life. Strong lesson planning and engaging classroom activities can help you accomplish those goals, but it's okay if things aren't flawless. Making mistakes as an educator can actually help your students and colleagues learn. It also reveals opportunities to hone your skills and grow as an educator.
Strategies to manage your inner perfectionist
According to the RAND report, 25% of teachers plan to leave their positions within 12 months and 70% of those teachers said they were considering leaving because of stress and disappointment in their positions. Due to their nature, teaching jobs do carry significant work demands. Making unrealistic demands of yourself only makes that load heavier.
Learning strategies to cope with perfectionism can help improve teacher wellbeing and empower school leaders to better support staff. Of course, it's important to get help with your wellbeing if your feelings of depression, anxiety, or perfectionism have become overwhelming or unmanageable.
Look past black-and-white thinking
Perfectionism is characterized by black-and-white thinking, or the tendency to see things as all or nothing. When perfectionists adopt this all-or-nothing attitude, they find that they've failed and get discouraged.
Education staff can resist all-or-nothing tendencies by practicing dialectical thinking instead. Dialectical thinking is seeing and accepting things from different perspectives. Educators who think in black and white tend to say things like, "My lesson didn't go well, and I've failed my students."
Teachers who practice dialectical thinking take an optimistic approach instead. They say things like, "My lesson didn't go as planned, but my students were still engaged and learned the material."
School leaders can support education staff wellbeing and their own mental health by encouraging teachers to adopt a growth mindset. This type of mindset insulates staff against perfectionism and helps them develop greater resilience.
Talk back to your inner critic
Almost everyone has a voice in their head that criticizes their work, appearance, and decision-making skills. This voice is known as your 'inner critic.' Turning down the volume on your inner critic can help you let go of perfectionism.
Education staff encourage their students to focus on the positive and try again when they get something wrong. It's time to practice that same compassion with yourself. Remind yourself that you deserve to be an educator and are doing your best for your students. The more you talk back to your inner critic, the less it will bother you.
School leaders can benefit from talking back to their inner critics too. Superintendents, principals, and other school leaders face immense pressure, and they tend to be very hard on themselves. Take time to jot down your professional accomplishments and remind your inner critic that you are qualified for your position.
Chant a calming mantra
A mantra is a phrase or sound that you chant repeatedly. You can say a mantra out loud, or you can keep it to yourself. Mantras have been shown to help calm the brain so that you can stop perfectionist thinking before it starts.
Educators can use positive affirmations as mantras. You can use a simple phrase like "I am a good teacher" or "My lesson plan is good enough" to get your brain back on track when perfectionism sneaks in.
School leaders can consider introducing a new mantra (or motto) to their staff for the school year or term. Examples include "progress not perfection" and "see the good."
Practice compassion with yourself
Both educators and school leaders benefit from practicing compassion with themselves. We know it's hard, but it's essential to accept your shortfallings. Instead of beating yourself up when something doesn't go well, quickly identify what you'll do instead next time and let it go. Focus on forgiving yourself and growing as an educator instead of berating yourself.
Managing your inner perfectionist can be challenging. Why not sign up for your free
Welbee Wellbeing toolkit today? You'll find tons of resources, videos, and courses to boost education staff wellbeing in your toolkit.